Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.
Comment: Migration of unmigrated content due to installation of a new plugin

Decisions:

 Summary
Description
  
  

Action Items: FYI, all of these have been resolved; therefore, I did not open any JIRA items to track ~ Laura 12/14/16

Summary
Description
Responsible
Due Date
Do interviews with individuals to tease out the value of XSEDE vs. SP resources
Jira
showSummaryfalse
serverXSEDE JIRA
serverId845344bc-9cbc-3ef7-9de2-01d3e3061f8e
keyQMA-110
 Craig Stewart12/31/2016
How to quantify "we couldn't have done this work without XSEDE"
Jira
showSummaryfalse
serverXSEDE JIRA
serverId845344bc-9cbc-3ef7-9de2-01d3e3061f8e
keyQMA-111
 Craig Stewart12/31/2016

Ralph - RAS section, every completed project that doesn't come back for renewal needs to submit a final report. Could add a question in that final report

Jira
showSummaryfalse
serverXSEDE JIRA
serverId845344bc-9cbc-3ef7-9de2-01d3e3061f8e
keyQMA-112
 Craig Stewart12/31/2016
Talk with Greg regarding Operations value
Jira
showSummaryfalse
serverXSEDE JIRA
serverId845344bc-9cbc-3ef7-9de2-01d3e3061f8e
keyQMA-113
 Craig Stewart12/31/2016
Consider Garnder assessment, per John – UIUC has connection
Jira
showSummaryfalse
serverXSEDE JIRA
serverId845344bc-9cbc-3ef7-9de2-01d3e3061f8e
keyQMA-114
 Craig Stewart12/31/2016
Slide 10 typo Greta to Great, if using these slides in the future
Jira
showSummaryfalse
serverXSEDE JIRA
serverId845344bc-9cbc-3ef7-9de2-01d3e3061f8e
keyQMA-115
 Craig Stewart12/31/2016

Consider the usefulness of presenting the ROI discussion in the same structure as the L2 areas

Jira
showSummaryfalse
serverXSEDE JIRA
serverId845344bc-9cbc-3ef7-9de2-01d3e3061f8e
keyQMA-116
 Craig Stewart12/31/2016
Consider looking at the analysis and then driving ROI
Jira
showSummaryfalse
serverXSEDE JIRA
serverId845344bc-9cbc-3ef7-9de2-01d3e3061f8e
keyQMA-117
 Craig Stewart12/31/2016
Consider discussing ROI with UAC
Jira
showSummaryfalse
serverXSEDE JIRA
serverId845344bc-9cbc-3ef7-9de2-01d3e3061f8e
keyQMA-118
 Craig Stewart12/31/2016
Consider the cost for a user and the value of ECSS alone
Jira
showSummaryfalse
serverXSEDE JIRA
serverId845344bc-9cbc-3ef7-9de2-01d3e3061f8e
keyQMA-119
 Craig Stewart12/31/2016

Notes:

  • Good ideas but not sure how many people will say 
  • What is the result of those who say they couldn't have done this work without XSEDE and why
    • compare their 3-year numbers with our 3-year numbers
  • Value of XSEDE as an organization vs. the SP Forum
  • Need to quantify XSEDE's role in making these services available to the nation
  • Quantify "we couldn't have done this work without XSEDE"
  • Ralph - RAS section, every completed project that doesn't come back for renewal needs to submit a final report. Could add a question in that final report
  • Working toward economic development and workforce development actions
  • IDC analysis quality a concern
  • ROI for XSEDE vs. ROI of the surrounding ecosystem – that distinction drifts further as the presentation goes on. Where you could argue that the XSEDE impact is limited.
  • Consider the usefulness of presenting the ROI discussion in the same structure as the L2 areas
  • Looking at the analysis and driving ROI